February 28, 2015: Jot and tittles of which law?

Lent Day 11: What I Believe, Chapter 5

In Chapter 5 Tolstoy splits hairs over the Church’s 1600-year-old interpretation of pivotal point in Christian doctrine: Jesus support or non-support of the written Hebrew law. But the little point he disputes is one on which the entire history of the world balances and, it might be argued, its destiny depends.

The Torah

The Torah

Tolstoy examines the two meanings of the word “law” as it is used in the Gospels. In Tolstoy’s new found understanding, Jesus is calling people to abandon the existing law, as expressed in the Hebrew scripture, and embrace the higher law of God. The law of God is not new, is in fact eternal, and is hinted at and alluded to in the old scriptures, but it is not the law that humans have, hitherto, ever followed.

The old – or Mosaic law – is based on retribution for wrongs and protecting our rights (“i.e., “an eye for an eye, a tooth for tooth”). This very human-based approach to organizing societal order is the root of our criminal code and our systems of law enforcement and methods of punishment. The law of God, which Jesus was teaching, is based on a completely different foundation. Rather than being built on a foundation of fear of punishment, this law is built on a foundation of love, non-violence, and putting the needs of others before self.

Since the New Testament scriptures continually refer the law this and the law that, it is easy for humans to misunderstand, and even to purposefully misinterpret Jesus’ message to mean what it does not mean: that He came not to abolish the old law but to confirm it. This little point, whether Jesus meant to confirm or abolish the old law, makes a rather essential difference in what it means to be a Christian, and how we ought to live if we want to live lives of genuine truth and meaning .

Tolstoy focuses on the key verses in this controversy: Matthew 5:17-19. These verses, he says, always bothered him. I’m glad to know I am not the only one. The passage reads, “Do not think that I have come to destroy the law or the prophets. I have not come to destroy, but to fulfill. For truly I say to you, until heaven and earth pass, not one jot or one tittle shall in no way pass from the law, until all is fulfilled.”

Well the Church, meaning nearly all denominations, have jumped all over those words and proclaimed them as proof that Jesus was all for the Mosaic (as written) law. But wait just a minute! says Tolstoy. Does is not give you pause that Jesus, who is all about forgiveness of sin, who stopped the stoning of a woman, who broke the rules of the Sabbath, who tells people to take the moat out their own eye before judging the specks in other peoples’ eyes, should suddenly be okay with all the bizarre and harsh laws of the Old Testament: stoning, killing disobedient children, poking out eyes, etc.? Something, says Tolstoy, is wrong with this picture.

Can we resolve this disturbing inconsistency? Tolstoy says yes. Once we see this verse in its correct interpretation, once we identify the error, the puzzle pieces fall will into place and the inconsistency will disappear. Next: Tolstoy explains the error.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Shelly Frey Psychic Medium

"Grief is not a sign of weakness, it's just the price we pay for love and it is worth every penny!"

You Can Trust Him.

God's Faithfulness for the Grieving Parent

Memory Bears by Bonnie

To Hold and Hug as You Remember

Through the Looking-Glass

"We're all mad here." "How do you know I'm mad?" "You must be,” said the Cat, “or you wouldn’t have come here.”


Humanity ... the manifestation of the Ego and enemy of Truth

The Chatsworth Lady

gardening, jewelry, beautiful things....

Jules Verne Times Two

The more we travel the bigger the world gets

Grief: One Woman's Perspective

Perceptions on life after the death of a child

I say this with love

Writing in relentless pursuit of truth


You've reached the Creative Space of Antiguan and Barbudan writer Joanne C. Hillhouse. Author of six books of fiction; and numerous short fiction, poems, and articles. Welcome. For info on my writing, services, and more, scroll down. If you need to contact me directly, email jhohadli@gmail.com. I update this space regularly; book reviews to news of my own books, #theWritingLife, and my CREATIVE SPACE column. Sharing with links and credits is fine but unauthorized use and/or duplication of site content without permission and credit is strictly prohibited. For my other blog, go to wadadlipen.wordpress.com

An Empire of Stories

Where fiction comes to life


A source for recommendations and the bloggers perspective


Let's Live, Love and Share our opinions about life, writing and more!!

%d bloggers like this: